The Entire 7 minute clip is worth listening to but there is a 1.5 minute section that particularly caught my attention.
Ordinary tyranny wants your obedience. It silences you, it frightens you but it leaves your inner world more or less intact. You may think what you like so long as you keep quiet. Total domination wants more than that – it wants the inside.
It runs on two engines. Terror – which isolates every person until no one will act with anyone else. And an ideology that claims to explain all of history past and future with airtight logic so that no fact can ever contradict it.
Now here is the most importance sentence I can give you, The ideal subject of such a regime is not a fanatic, the true believer who burns with conviction It is the person for whom the difference between fact and fiction, between true and false has simply stopped existing. The one who no longer trusts what they saw with their own eyes over what they have been told. Once enough people reach that stage anything becomes possible because there is no longer any solid ground from which to say that is a lie. You do not have to make people believe The Lie. You just have to wear them down until they no longer believe anything at all. Exhaustion not conviction is the goal.
Modern medicine
As outlined in Whose Fault are the Suicides, what Hannah Arendt is saying here comes close to the totalitarian situation we now have with prescription-only medicines.
Too many of us are now unable to trust what we see with our own eyes over what we have been told. This means there is no longer any solid ground from which to say that this is a lie. The drug labels and the guidelines have exhausted doctors in particular,
Everywhere else insurance makes it possible for us to do things – travel, drive, climb whatever. I was about to say makes health possible. But our insurance now gives us problems (minor risk factors) and your doctor is not allowed to tell you that if it were her she would not be taking this lipid lowering or bone thickening drug.
Doctors really have their legs cut from under them when their insurers tell them to stick to the facts – you prescribed this drug on that day at this dose to that person who committed suicide. They do not support you to say you can see nothing other than the drug that could have caused this suicide or nothing but drug withdrawal for which other doctors are giving you an FND label.
The result is that doctors cannot stand with us, their patients, When, as Hannah says, standing together is the only thing that can enable us to resist a tyrannous force. Power comes from people standing together.
Fjord
It’s easier to point out this brutal truth after seeing Fjord – the movie that won this year’s Palme D’Or Prize at the Cannes Film Festival.
In a desperate situation, not unlike the situation we have with prescription medicines now, Fjord holds out hope. An extraordinary movie that has shaken many people who hold points of view they would previously have considered as diametrically opposite to their own.
It’s storyline centers on the inability of bureaucracies to work for people. We need leadership to take us beyond bureaucracy. To get us to realize that rules, even law itself, are tools that like medicines or guns are not in themselves good or bad. It takes US to bring good out of them.
And the leadership doesn’t necessarily come from where you might expect. This is caught in one of the most daring (blink and you will miss them) moments you will ever see in any movie – echoing a weird and perilous moment for a bunch of fishermen long ago who needed saving by someone who could walk on water – as it were.
Fjord suggests our salvation will come from Girls. Women are the movers in Fjord – like Rashmi, Katinka and Kim in Whose Fault are the Suicides. But watching Fjord you need to keep an eye on the two Girls.
I’d have said Unforgettable but nowhere does the feature imagery for this movie feature the two Girls who are key. We maybe miss what happens in history because women tend to stay in the background.,

Leave a Reply